![]()
The Supreme Court has rejected President Trump’s executive order ending birthright citizenship, ruling 6-3 that children born in the United States to illegal immigrants and temporary visa holders remain U.S. citizens under the 14th Amendment.
Justice Clarence Thomas, who disagreed with the Supreme Court’s decision, argued that the Court got the history wrong. He wrote that the 14th Amendment was intended to secure citizenship for freed slaves, “not… the children of foreign temporary visitors and illegal aliens.” He also said the amendment “has instead been repurposed for political projects that the Reconstruction Congress did not support.”
Thomas’s view was that because much of the application of Trump’s Day 1 executive order was “consistent with the original public meaning” of the clause in the 14th Amendment, it should have been upheld.
If Thomas is right about the amendment’s original purpose, then this ruling isn’t preserving the Constitution but instead redefining it.
President Trump called the ruling “Too bad for our Country,” adding that Republicans could “easily make up for it in Congress through legislation.”
In another major ruling, all nine Supreme Court justices agreed that states can prohibit transgender athletes from competing in female school and college sports without violating Title IX, the 1972 federal law prohibiting sex discrimination in education.
Trump said the decision was a “big win,” and so did many others.
Not everyone agrees, though. Defenders of LGBTQ rights say the decision opens the door to discrimination. But what about biological girls? Don’t they have rights too?
According to the Court, they do.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh made that clear when he pointed out that forcing women and girls to compete against males would “deny equal opportunity to female athletes because, as all agree, females and males have inherent physical differences.”
Yesterday was a good day for girls’ sports. Young women shouldn’t have to sacrifice the opportunities they spent years working toward or their safety just to satisfy someone else’s ideology.